A True Game Changer for Submarine Self Defence against Threats from
Text and interview by Xavier Vavasseur
As part of the Paris Air Show Navy Recognition was invited by DCNS to
visit their factory located near Angoulême in southwestern France.
The 260 year old site used to manufacture guns for the "French
Royal Navy". It now specializes in the production of submarine
equipment such as torpedo tubes and torpedo handling systems. It is
also the place where the FREMM frigates' vertical launch systems are
produced. The focus of the visit however was the A3SM, a new anti-air
defence weapon system for submarine currently under development by DCNS
from both DCNS and MBDA gave us exclusive details on the A3SM project
during our visit of the DCNS factory in Ruelle near Angoulême,
stands for Arme Anti-Aérienne pour Sous Marins (literally Anti-Air
Weapon for Submarines). The project was first unveiled during Euronaval
2012 and it actually consists in two versions: a Mast version and an
Underwater Vehicle version.
A3SM: What needs does it fulfill?
Today, submarines have no way to defend themselves against air threats.
Submarine forces worldwide have an increasing need to operate close
to shores in shallow waters. (As an example during the campaign in Libya,
submarines were conducting intelligence missions close to shores). In
such situation submarines are an easy target for helicopters and maritime
patrol aircraft (MPA). When detected in shallow waters, there is no
possibility for the submarine to escape, contrary to deep sea where
they can employ various tactics and disappear. Up until now, submarines
were harmless against air threats, while significantly cheaper and less
complex naval platform like small Fast Attack Craft (FAC) may be fitted
with a SAM solution.
It is this gap that DCNS and MBDA are looking to fill. The doctrine
of use is not for the submarine to attack first. The submarine will
keep trying to escape when faced with an air threat as it has always
been the case. However the submarine will shoot it down if escape is
This fast reaction scenario leaves little time to react therefore calls
for ready to fire, fire and forget weapons at all time.
systems may be fitted on the full range of DCNS Submarines
A3SM: How does it work?
For target designation, the submarine crew needs some of the following
data from the target: its bearing, its range, its speed or its course.
When submerged the crew will use acoustic detection to acquire this
data. If faced with a helicopter with dipping sonar, the crew will get
its bearing, its speed (virtually 0) and its approximate altitude which
is enough aquire the target with accuracy. If faced with an MPA, the
crew will know a threat is in the area. If the submarine is detected
it will employ tactics to go to periscope depth and acquire the MPA
with its optronics systems.
This is all consistent with current submarine missions: When a helicopter
dips its sonar, its behavior is considered aggressive by the submarine.
Same thing when a MPA detects the submarine thanks to its active sonobuoys.
DCNS offers two solutions to give the choice to its customers. The mast
version has shorter range but doesn't impact the maximum payload of
the submarine. It is the suggested choice for smaller platforms such
as the Andrasta which has provision for only 6 weapons. The mast version
would actually increase the payload of Andrasta.
Vehicle Version with Mica IR
Underwater Vehicle Version:
The underwater vehicle version comprises a torpedo-like capsule (the
VSM) containing a medium-range (20 km) Mica missile that is tube-launchable
at any depth. The capsule is similar to the type developed for submarine-launched
SM 39 Exocet anti-ship missiles, a proven system which exists for 35
years now. The missile is based on VL Mica (launched from surface vessels)
which has already been procured by several navies. MICA covers Beyond
Visual Range situations offering additionally 2 guidance systems with
its 2 interoperable seekers:
• RF MICA with radar seeker providing all weather shoot-up / shoot
• IR MICA with dual waveband imaging infrared seeker
VL Mica has a range of up to 20 Km and reaches speeds in excess of Mach
3. A3SM underwater vehicle version with Mica missile can be considered
a medium range solution to be deployed when submerged.
For submarine launch, MBDA selected the IR version because of the characteristics
of the threats: Helicopters and MPAs have low Doppler signature and
IR is a better match against these types of targets. The 12 Kg warhead
of the Mica guarantees a "full kill" capability against both
types. Fitted with thrust vectoring, Mica has very high maneuverability
(proven against anti-ship missiles) which leaves little to no escape
opportunities for slow moving targets such as ASW helicopters and MPAs.
The thrust vectoring of Mica allows it to be fired when the submarine
is cruising away from the threat. In addition the VSM (torpedo-like
capsule holding the Mica) is powered by a rocket engine and has the
ability to maneuver underwater, meaning the Mica may attack its target
from any angles and catch the helicopter or MPA crew off guard.
The VSM was adapted to provide the same launch environment as when a
VL Mica is launched from a vertical launch system. All the other steps
(launch from the submarine, underwater step, breach of the surface and
air step) remain exactly the same as for the SM39 therefore are already
validated. MBDA basically merged 2 existing concepts into a single one:
SM39 + VL Mica. The only modifications are found inside the VSM. Some
adaptation work was conducted to fir the Mica which is a smaller missile
than Exocet. The other focus is behavior at the launch: Mica accelerates
very quickly therefore exhaust gas management is different.
version comes with a missile housing containing 3 Mistral missiles and
an IR camera
The mast version comprises a missile housing (that remains watertight
throughout the submarine’s operating range and down to maximum
diving depth) mounted on a hoistable mast and containing three short-range
MBDA Mistral 2 missiles that can be fired from periscope depth. DCNS
is in charge of developing the launching system. Mistral 2 is a lightweight,
fully digital, heat seeking missile with a maximum range of 6.5 Km and
maximum speed of Mach 2.5. An Infra-Red camera from SAGEM is fitted
in the missile housing to act as optronic aiming sight. A3SM Mast version
with Mistral missile can be considered a short range solution to be
deployed from periscope depth.
Contrary to Mica missile, the Mistral requires to be locked on target
before launch. The Mistral's homing guidance with an infra-red seeker
is reported to be the best solution against helicopters and MPAs. A3SM
mast version may shoot on the move and in any directions which is an
important feature as reaction time is key for self defence. Thanks to
its compact nature (less than 20 Kg, less than 2 meters) three Mistrals
can be fitted in the mast. When back in port, the whole canister may
be replaced by a new one. Loading of the Mistrals in the canister occur
in a dedicated facility.
Mistral is fitted on most vessels of the French Navy, from the aircraft
carrier to patrol boats. It has shown its capability against many types
of targets: anti-ship missiles, helicopters and fast jets. MBDA has
extensive experience integrating the Mistral on many platform and launchers
(fixed, vehicles, helicopters, ships...) and see no difference in integrating
the Mistral to the DCNS launcher. DCNS goal with the existing mast prototype
is to qualify the movement of the canister
A3SM: A Game changer
DCNS and MBDA insist there is no missile development required as both
missiles are already proven solution, which significantly reduces risk
and cost. Both versions will be fully integrated with Subtics combat
DCNS and MBDA already submitted offers to several potential customers
and stand ready to finalize the development once they get a contract.
They estimate it could take as little as 2 to 3 years between contract
signature and IOC.
A3SM weapon systems for submarines can be considered a game changer
because the rules of anti--submarine warfare are indeed about to change.
While submarines will certainly not start conducting anti--helicopter
or anti-MPAs patrols, they will soon have means to take action and defend
themselves in case of absolute necessity while in the past ASW helicopters
and MPAs could keep on engaging a detected submarine over and over again
without fear of retaliation. A3SM will act as deterrence for submarines
and keep ASW helicopters and MPAs at bay in the near future.
Pictures of YJ-12 supersonic anti-ship missile, fitted on a Chinese
Navy (PLAN) Xian H-6G bomber have recently emerged on the Chinese internet
meaning this new generation missile may have entered operational service.